Focus on Cellulose ethers

Comparison of Hydroxyethyl Cellulose (HEC) and Other Cellulose Ethers

Hydroxyethyl Cellulose (HEC) and other cellulose ethers (such as hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), methylcellulose (MC), hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC) and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC)) are multifunctional polymers widely used in industry, construction, medicine, food and daily chemical industries. These cellulose derivatives are made by chemically modifying cellulose and have good water solubility, thickening, stability and film-forming properties.

1. Hydroxyethyl Cellulose (HEC)

1.1 Chemical Structure and Properties

Hydroxyethyl Cellulose (HEC) is made by hydroxyethylation of cellulose with ethylene oxide under alkaline conditions. The basic structure of HEC is an ether bond formed by the replacement of the hydroxyl group in the cellulose molecule by a hydroxyethyl group. This structure gives HEC unique properties:

Water solubility: HEC is soluble in both cold and hot water to form a transparent colloidal solution.

Thickening: HEC has excellent thickening properties and is widely used in applications requiring viscosity control.
Stability: HEC solution has high stability in different pH ranges.
Biocompatibility: HEC is non-toxic, non-irritating, and friendly to the human body and the environment.
1.2 Application fields
Building materials: used as thickener and water retaining agent for cement mortar and gypsum products.
Coatings and paints: used as thickener, suspending agent and stabilizer.
Daily chemicals: used as thickener in daily necessities such as detergents and shampoos.
Pharmaceutical field: used as adhesive, thickener and suspending agent for drug tablets.
1.3 Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages: good water solubility, chemical stability, wide pH adaptability and non-toxicity.
Disadvantages: poor solubility in some solvents, and the price may be slightly higher than some other cellulose ethers.
2. Comparison of other cellulose ethers
2.1 Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC)
2.1.1 Chemical structure and properties
HPMC is made from cellulose through methylation and hydroxypropylation reactions. Its structure contains both methoxy (-OCH3) and hydroxypropoxy (-OCH2CH(OH)CH3) substitutions.
Water solubility: HPMC dissolves in cold water to form a transparent colloidal solution; it has poor solubility in hot water.
Thickening property: It has excellent thickening ability.
Gelling properties: It forms a gel when heated and returns to its original state when cooled.

2.1.2 Application areas
Building materials: It is used as a thickener and water retaining agent for cement-based and gypsum-based materials.
Food: It is used as an emulsifier and stabilizer.
Medicine: It is used as an excipient for pharmaceutical capsules and tablets.

2.1.3 Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages: Good thickening performance and gelling properties.
Disadvantages: It is sensitive to temperature and may fail in high temperature applications.

2.2 Methyl cellulose (MC)

2.2.1 Chemical structure and properties
MC is obtained by methylation of cellulose and mainly contains methoxy (-OCH3) substitutions.
Water solubility: dissolves well in cold water to form a transparent colloidal solution.
Thickening: has a significant thickening effect.
Thermal gelation: forms a gel when heated and degels when cooled.

2.2.2 Application areas
Building materials: used as a thickener and water retainer for mortar and paint.
Food: used as an emulsifier and stabilizer.

2.2.3 Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages: strong thickening ability, often used in cold processing technology.
Disadvantages: heat-sensitive, cannot be used at high temperatures.

2.3 Hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC)

2.3.1 Chemical structure and properties
HPC is obtained by hydroxypropyl cellulose. Its structure contains hydroxypropoxy (-OCH2CH(OH)CH3).
Water solubility: dissolves in cold water and organic solvents.
Thickening: good thickening performance.
Film-forming property: forms a strong film.

2.3.2 Application fields
Medicine: used as coating material and tablet excipient for drugs.
Food: used as thickener and stabilizer.

2.3.3 Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages: multi-solvent solubility and excellent film-forming property.
Disadvantages: high price.

2.4 Carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC)

2.4.1 Chemical structure and characteristics
CMC is made by reacting cellulose with chloroacetic acid, and contains carboxymethyl group (-CH2COOH) in its structure.
Water solubility: soluble in cold water and hot water.
Thickening property: significant thickening effect.
Ionicity: belongs to anionic cellulose ether.

2.4.2 Application fields
Food: used as thickener and stabilizer.
Daily chemicals: used as thickener for detergent.
Papermaking: used as additive for paper coating.

2.4.3 Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages: good thickening and wide application fields.
Disadvantages: sensitive to electrolytes, ions in solution may affect performance.

3. Comprehensive comparison

3.1 Thickening performance

HEC and HPMC have similar thickening performance and both have good thickening effect. However, HEC has better water solubility and is suitable for applications requiring transparency and low irritation. HPMC is more useful in applications that require heating to gel due to its thermogel properties.

3.2 Water solubility

HEC and CMC can both be dissolved in cold and hot water, while HPMC and MC are mainly dissolved in cold water. HPC is preferred when multi-solvent compatibility is required.

3.3 Price and application range

HEC is usually moderately priced and widely used. Although HPC has excellent performance, it is usually used in high-demand applications due to its high cost. CMC has a place in many low-cost applications with its low cost and good performance.

Hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC) has become one of the most widely used cellulose ethers due to its good water solubility, stability and thickening ability. Compared with other cellulose ethers, HEC has certain advantages in water solubility and chemical stability, and is suitable for applications that require transparent solutions and wide pH adaptability. HPMC excels in certain specific areas due to its thickening and thermal gelling properties, while HPC and CMC occupy an important position in their respective application fields due to their film-forming properties and cost advantages. According to specific application requirements, choosing the right cellulose ether can optimize product performance and cost-effectiveness.


Post time: Jul-10-2024
WhatsApp Online Chat !